[農場] Braves 2019 Top 20 Prospects(Sickels)

看板Braves作者 (嘴砲型的效率)時間6年前 (2018/10/30 10:39), 編輯推噓28(28041)
留言69則, 17人參與, 6年前最新討論串1/1
1.老問題 潛力新秀常常還是一狗票投手 打者很薄 JS這個第1給的很中肯 勇勇一狗票投手中 看起來 有ace潛力只有Ian Anderson 如果TT快速球的控 球能更棒 也會很接近 Kyle Wright過譽了 希望明年能給我打臉 2.因為畢業了不少人 今年B以上只剩14個 JS寫的 第一隊雙城B以上的就有19個 目前看看整體還有 沒有前10 前5是很難了 3.沒想到JS對Allard這麼有信心 大家快來買 1) Ian Anderson, RHP, Grade A-: Age 20, first round pick from high school in New York in 2016, posted 2.49 ERA in 119 innings between High-A and Double-A, with 142/49 K/BB, only 87 hits and two homers allowed all year; plus fastball, curveball and change-up have all developed nicely, throws strikes, no deterioration in performance after being promoted; in my opinion he has the best combination of upside and polish of all the Braves pitching prospects; ETA late 2019. 2) Mike Soroka, RHP, Grade B+/A-: Age 21, first round pick in 2015 from high school in Canada, posted 1.76 ERA in 31 innings between Triple-A and a Low-A rehab outing, 34/6 K/BB, just 20 hits; posted 3.51 ERA in 25.2 major league innings with 21/7 K/BB; pitching time limited by shoulder problems; reports on recovery are good but shoulder stuff is inherently scary and knocks his grade down a notch from what it would otherwise be; he’s ready for a rotation spot if healthy; ETA 2019. 3) Touki Toussaint, RHP, Grade B+: Age 22, famously electric arm with fastball up to 98 and nasty breaking ball; took huge step forward with his command this year, posting 2.38 ERA with 163/57 K/BB in 136 innings between Double-A and Triple-A, just 101 hits; posted 4.03 ERA in 29 major league innings with 32/21 K/BB, just 18 hits; it is all a matter of control, stuff is too good for the minors at this point so he may have some ups and downs in the majors for a year or two to put the finishing touches on his command; ETA 2019. 4) Kyle Wright, RHP, Grade B+: Age 23, first round pick in 2017 out of Vanderbilt, posted 3.46 ERA in 133/51 K/BB in 138 innings between Double-A and Triple-A, 118 hits; threw six innings in the majors with five strikeouts, six walks; fastball in mid-90s, mixed in with slider, cutter, change-up; overpowering on the right day but can be inconsistent with his command and have some games when he gets blown up, reminds me some of Kevin Gausman at the same stage; ETA 2019. 5) Kolby Allard, LHP, Grade B+: Age 21, first round pick in 2015, posted 2.72 ERA in 112 innings in Triple-A with 89/34 K/BB, 102 hits; gave up 19 hits in eight innings in the majors with 12.38 ERA; he’s obviously better than that; doesn’t have the pure stuff of the guys above him but certainly no slouch and can throw fastball, curve, change-up for quality strikes when he’s going well; I like him more than some other analysts do for intuitive reasons I can ’t explain very clearly; ETA 2019. 6) Austin Riley, 3B, Grade B+: Age 21, comp round pick in 2015 from high school in Mississippi; hit .294/.360/.522 with 30 doubles, 19 homers, 37 walks, 129 strikeouts in 408 at-bats between Double-A and Triple-A; defense has improved dramatically over the last two years and he’s proven he can get to his raw power; approach is aggressive and strikeout/contact concerns could inhibit OBP and batting average when he reaches the majors; that said, I am optimistic about him; ETA 2019. 7) Cristian Pache, OF, Grade B+: Age 19, signed out of the Dominican Republic in 2015; hit .279/.307/.410 with nine homers, 20 walks, 97 strikeouts in 473 at-bats between High-A and Double-A; very young for these levels; stands out for arm strength, 70-grade speed and strong defense; began to develop power this year after hitting zero homers in 2017; still some uncertainties about his approach but extremely impressive to see in person, tools are obviously stand-out and the skills are coming along; ETA 2020. 8) Luiz Gohara, LHP, Grade B+: Age 22, out of Brazil, posted 4.81 ERA with 59/18 K/BB in 58 innings in Double-A/Triple-A with 5.95 ERA, 18/8 K/BB in 20 major league innings; progressed stalled this year with nagging injuries and distracting family crises; I remain intrigued with his upside and still believe he can become a dominant pitcher if he can get a handle on the off-field stuff and stay healthy; Wayne Cavadi compares him to CC Sabathia in terms of upside potential and I can see that, keeping in mind that CC was also erratic in his early MLB exposure; ETA 2019. 9) Bryse Wilson, RHP, Grade B+: Age 20, fourth round pick in 2016 out of high school, posted 3.44 ERA with 143/36 K/BB in 126 innings between High-A, Double-A, Triple-A; posted 6/6 K/BB in seven major league innings; looks like potential workhorse with 90+ sinker, slider, and change-up combined with good control; doesn’t get as much press as the guys ahead of him but may end up being just as successful; would be the top pitching prospect in many systems. ETA 2019. 10) Drew Waters, OF, Grade B/B+: Age 19, second round pick in 2017 from high school in Georgia; hit .293/.343/.476 with 39 doubles, nine homers, 29 walks, 105 strikeouts, 23 steals in 460 at-bats between High-A and Double-A; switch-hitter with plus running speed, still learning to tap his power though high doubles total is promising; another Braves hitter with aggressive approach leading to OBP questions as he moves up but young enough to make needed adjustments. ETA 2021. 11) Kyle Muller, LHP, Grade B: Age 21, second round pick in 2016 from high school in Texas; posted 3.03 ERA with 129/46 K/BB in 140 innings between Low-A, High-A, and Double-A; fastball velocity can be inconsistent but he throws strikes and has made good progress developing curveball and change-up; easy to overlook given the depth of pitching in this system; ETA late 2019. 12) Joey Wentz, LHP, Grade B: Age 21, comp round pick in 2016 from high school in Kansas, limited to 67 innings by nagging injuries but pitched well when healthy, 2.28 ERA with 53/24 K/BB, 49 hits in High-A; like Muller he has a respectable low-90s fastball and an assortment of classic southpaw secondaries; K-rate declined this year which bears watching; ETA 2020. 13) William Contreras, C, Grade B: Age 21, signed out of Venezuela in 2015, brother of Willson Contreras; hit .285/.347/.436 between Low-A and High-A with 11 homers, 35 walks, 89 strikeouts in 390 at-bats; defense needs more polish (19 errors), has throwing arm and mobility to be a fine catcher but still working out the kinks, should improve with experience; power developing well and he controls the strike zone reasonably; has a shot as a regular with continued development; ETA late 2020. 14) Tristan Beck, RHP, Grade B-/B: Age 22, fourth round pick in 2018 out of Stanford, threw 4.2 innings without allowing a run in rookie ball; college career was marred by injuries but effective when healthy with low-90s fastball, slightly above-average curve, and plus change-up; relatively polished and could move quickly through the system if he manages a pro workload successfully; ETA 2021. 15) Wes Parsons, RHP, Grade C+: Age 26, older prospect but with a solid track record, 2.76 ERA with 104/35 K/BB in 117 innings between Double-A and Triple-A, 101 hits allowed; the youngsters ahead of him throw harder and have gaudier press clippings but Parsons throws strikes with four average pitches (two-seam, four-seam, slider, change-up) and has nothing left to prove in the minors; fourth starter/long relief type but should not be underestimated; ETA 2019. 16) Freddy Tarnok, RHP, Grade C+: Age 19, third round pick in 2017 from high school in Florida; posted 3.96 ERA in 77 innings in Low-A with 83/41 K/BB, 70 hits; raw, still learning how to pitch rather than just throw; curveball and change-up inconsistent but flash well to go with his fastball up to 95; needs to improve command and control but a high ceiling; ETA 2022. 17) Greyson Jenista, OF, Grade C+: Age 21, second round pick out of Wichita State, hit .333/.377/.453 in 117 at-bats in Low-A but slumped to .152/.230/.227 in 66 at-bats in High-A; lefty hitter with 6-4, 210 pound build, plus power potential, also runs and throws well, I saw a lot of him in college and he’s dangerous when his swing mechanics are in gear but can be inconsistent on days when he loses the strike zone; ETA 2021. 18) Chad Sobotka, RHP, Grade C+: Age 25, fourth round pick in 2014 from South Carolina-Upstate; posted 2.03 ERA in 58 innings between in High-A/Double-A/Triple-A, 77/29 K/BB, just 30 hits allowed; posted 1.88 ERA in 14 major league innings with 21/9 K/BB; really opened eyes after poor 2017 seasons; mid-to-upper-90s fastball and hard slider make him promising bullpen asset if his command holds up; ETA 2019. 19) Huascar Ynoa, RHP, Grade C+: Age 20, acquired from Minnesota Twins in Jaime Garcia trae in 2017; posted 3.63 ERA in 92 innings in Low-A with 100/42 K/BB; hit hard in High-A with 8.03 ERA in 25 innings, 31/12 K/BB but 33 hits; struggles to keep mechanics consistent which hurts his command but there’s good stuff here with low-mid-90s fastball, slider and change-up; he’s in the right system to learn his craft; ETA 2022. 20) CJ Alexander, 3B, Grade C+: Age 22, 20th round pick in 2018 from State College of Florida; destroyed pro pitching at .352/.429/.495 in 196 at-bats between rookie ball and High-A, no loss of production at the higher levels; draft status was deceptive; he was considered a fourth round talent and it was a steal to get him in the 20th; in college had reputation as a power hitter; he hit just two homers as a pro but showed better than expected pure hitting skills; if he combines those two attributes, look out; ETA 2021. OTHER GRADE C+ (could fit in slots 15-20): Thomas Burrows, LHP; Corbin Clouse, LHP; Tucker Davidson, LHP; Justin Dean, OF; Jasseel De La Cruz, RHP; Riley Delgado, INF; AJ Graffanino, INF; Alex Jackson, C; Adam McCreery, LHP; Jefrey Ramos, OF; Trey Riley, RHP; Ricardo Sanchez, LHP; Jacob Webb, RHP; Patrick Weigel, RHP GRADE C: Derian Cruz, 2B; Victor De Hoyos, C; Travis Demeritte, OF; Ray-Patrick Didder, INF; Jeremy Fernandez, OF; Josh Graham, RHP; Trey Harris, OF; Miguel Jerez, LHP; Tanner Lawson, LHP; Drew Lugbauer, C-3B; Alan Rangel, RHP; Matt Rowland, RHP; Braulio Vasquez, INF; Jeremy Walker, RHP; Isranel Wilson, OF The Braves have an insane amount of pitching talent but are not nearly as deep in impact position players. I’m firm on Anderson at Number One and a healthy Soroka at Number Two but the next seven slots could be ordered 50 different ways with valid logic. Spots 15 to 20 are also fungible and I went through five or six different versions before settling on these guys as the most interesting of the bunch. -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 117.56.73.97 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Braves/M.1540867152.A.672.html

10/30 11:26, 6年前 , 1F
當初Folty評價是A嗎? 接下來幾年要爭冠希望有個ACE
10/30 11:26, 1F

10/30 13:22, 6年前 , 2F
Wright的控球有問題, 尤其是他的變化球控制跟變化
10/30 13:22, 2F

10/30 13:23, 6年前 , 3F
B+以上還是有10個,TWINS才4個,應該還是TOP 5農場
10/30 13:23, 3F

10/30 13:23, 6年前 , 4F
程度每場差異很大. 不過要說他目前是符合甚至略為
10/30 13:23, 4F

10/30 13:24, 6年前 , 5F
超前進度. 才第一個完整球季就打到MLB要說overrated
10/30 13:24, 5F

10/30 13:25, 6年前 , 6F
算是對他蠻苛求的
10/30 13:25, 6F

10/30 13:27, 6年前 , 7F
我沒有回去找Folty的評價, 不過依照Sickels的評斷法
10/30 13:27, 7F

10/30 13:27, 6年前 , 8F
Folty當年了不起是B左右, 要到B+會蠻困難的
10/30 13:27, 8F

10/30 13:29, 6年前 , 9F
他在太空人最後一年時候大概是有火球, 曲球好
10/30 13:29, 9F

10/30 13:29, 6年前 , 10F
控球很爛. 他的滑球跟變速球都是到了蛹蛹, 開始打
10/30 13:29, 10F

10/30 13:29, 6年前 , 11F
大聯盟後才一個一個練出來的, 控球也是今年才較穩
10/30 13:29, 11F

10/30 13:31, 6年前 , 12F
給到B已經是一個很好的評價, 就是MLB先發級有貢獻
10/30 13:31, 12F

10/30 13:32, 6年前 , 13F
選手, B+就已經是接近明星球員.
10/30 13:32, 13F

10/30 16:20, 6年前 , 14F
好好養 Beuhler我們也能有
10/30 16:20, 14F

10/30 16:26, 6年前 , 15F
看來FOLTY被我們養的還真好,為什麼球路到MLB才練啊
10/30 16:26, 15F

10/30 17:02, 6年前 , 16F
在太空人農場連最擅長的快速球跟曲球都丟不進好球帶
10/30 17:02, 16F

10/30 17:02, 6年前 , 17F
還要讓他練新球路嗎XDXD
10/30 17:02, 17F

10/30 18:22, 6年前 , 18F
快點綁Folty補償人家去年的0.1M無言仲裁吧
10/30 18:22, 18F

10/30 23:05, 6年前 , 19F
真的滿滿都是投手...Anderson明年會拉上來看看吧?
10/30 23:05, 19F

10/31 11:11, 6年前 , 20F
好投手最多只能維持不輸球 有好的打擊才能贏球
10/31 11:11, 20F

10/31 17:37, 6年前 , 21F
投手 打線 牛棚都很重要
10/31 17:37, 21F

10/31 22:46, 6年前 , 22F
不知有無可能盤來Clint Frazier,home town boy的說
10/31 22:46, 22F

11/02 00:51, 6年前 , 23F
從教士那換來Raffy Lopez
11/02 00:51, 23F

11/02 08:36, 6年前 , 24F
雞肋交易...XD
11/02 08:36, 24F

11/02 11:56, 6年前 , 25F
金寶跟麥肯會回來嗎?
11/02 11:56, 25F

11/02 17:19, 6年前 , 26F
那個換回來應該暫時會是3A主戰捕手吧
11/02 17:19, 26F

11/05 11:03, 6年前 , 27F
金手套中3個,恭喜自由人阿鐵MKKS
11/05 11:03, 27F

11/05 12:28, 6年前 , 28F
這次票選很有趣,感覺我們隊上真的防很好的Albies S
11/05 12:28, 28F

11/05 12:28, 6年前 , 29F
wanson Camargo Acuna 都沒提名
11/05 12:28, 29F

11/05 12:42, 6年前 , 30F
MKKS怎麼拿金手套了!
11/05 12:42, 30F

11/05 16:15, 6年前 , 31F
沒提名大概是因為還太嫩XD
11/05 16:15, 31F

11/07 10:30, 6年前 , 32F
Gohara 減了不少重量,想問總監大,單輪天賦Gohara
11/07 10:30, 32F

11/07 10:30, 6年前 , 33F
大概可以排在我們新秀投手的什麼位子
11/07 10:30, 33F

11/07 11:33, 6年前 , 34F
高大厚實的左手先發,94-98mph快速球,65-70的滑球
11/07 11:33, 34F

11/07 11:33, 6年前 , 35F
,50-55的變速球...控球身材態度都沒問題的話應該
11/07 11:33, 35F

11/07 11:33, 6年前 , 36F
至少在Touki之上,甚至可能是球界最好投手之一. 不
11/07 11:33, 36F

11/07 11:33, 6年前 , 37F
過現實世界是很難發生這種事的啦.
11/07 11:33, 37F

11/07 14:13, 6年前 , 38F
AA擺明要簽Closer了,金寶友情價回歸吧(誤)
11/07 14:13, 38F

11/07 14:18, 6年前 , 39F
在Touki 之上不是只剩Anderson 跟Soraka 了
11/07 14:18, 39F

11/07 15:08, 6年前 , 40F
他在2018年的確是排在勇士所有投手之上啊
11/07 15:08, 40F

11/07 15:14, 6年前 , 41F
年前BA跟JS的排名Gohara都是蛹蛹投手第一,只輸Acun
11/07 15:14, 41F

11/07 15:14, 6年前 , 42F
a. Gohara的天份從他被水手簽下來那一刻就是那麼棒
11/07 15:14, 42F

11/07 15:14, 6年前 , 43F
,讓他起伏不定的一直都是球場外因素.
11/07 15:14, 43F

11/07 18:52, 6年前 , 44F
還是不看好 Gohara 球場外的因素最麻煩
11/07 18:52, 44F

11/07 18:53, 6年前 , 45F
減了35磅搞不好連機制都跑掉了
11/07 18:53, 45F

11/07 18:55, 6年前 , 46F
沒必要急著出手Gohara吧,他身價要比現在還低也很難
11/07 18:55, 46F

11/07 18:55, 6年前 , 47F
給他一點時間重建身價,要上來補或是賣掉都比較好
11/07 18:55, 47F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 48F
個人是覺得他遲早會成功,但是要多遲真的很難講,在
11/07 22:03, 48F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 49F
現階段的蛹蛹也不見得有局數讓他玩,這是很尷尬的地
11/07 22:03, 49F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 50F
方. 打個比方來說,2年前的Folty放到今年蛹蛹也不
11/07 22:03, 50F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 51F
太可能就讓他這樣炸一年來練. Gohara不是急於出清
11/07 22:03, 51F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 52F
的小朋友,畢竟他還有options可以上上下下,年輕又
11/07 22:03, 52F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 53F
有天賦. 但是也不會是非賣品,因為現階段他問題不
11/07 22:03, 53F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 54F
少. 如果Gohara為主的包裹能換到Realmuto或是其他
11/07 22:03, 54F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 55F
很有價值的球員,哪我想AA應該會出手. 如果是拿Goha
11/07 22:03, 55F

11/07 22:03, 6年前 , 56F
ra去換像Duvall這種,就是腦袋有問題了吧.
11/07 22:03, 56F

11/07 23:31, 6年前 , 57F
記得Gohara 在水兵時期是個人紀律有點問題,今年就
11/07 23:31, 57F

11/07 23:31, 6年前 , 58F
完全是家庭因素(媽媽生病,過世?)去年他登板那幾
11/07 23:31, 58F

11/07 23:31, 6年前 , 59F
場的表現讓我真的好不想放掉他啊
11/07 23:31, 59F

11/08 01:20, 6年前 , 60F
官網說禮拜天我們已經丟了一個大包裹給魚參考要換真
11/08 01:20, 60F

11/08 01:20, 6年前 , 61F
木頭了
11/08 01:20, 61F

11/08 01:27, 6年前 , 62F
有人說官網引用的消息有誤...懷疑是大魚在炒
11/08 01:27, 62F

11/08 01:41, 6年前 , 63F
季前Gohara爸心臟病突發死在他懷裡,季初媽媽開心臟
11/08 01:41, 63F

11/08 01:41, 6年前 , 64F
記得好像是這樣
11/08 01:41, 64F

11/08 01:43, 6年前 , 65F
這樣官網的記者有點掉漆耶....
11/08 01:43, 65F

11/08 01:54, 6年前 , 66F
官網有寫那個消息還未經證實啦XD
11/08 01:54, 66F

11/08 06:21, 6年前 , 67F
我們挖了太色人的Mike Fast當GM特助,數據野球登場?
11/08 06:21, 67F

11/18 08:17, 6年前 , 68F
Davidson 在AFL的冠軍賽打了再見全壘打
11/18 08:17, 68F

11/18 08:17, 6年前 , 69F
然後跑壘的時候骨折了。。。Morales嗎?
11/18 08:17, 69F
文章代碼(AID): #1RryHGPo (Braves)
文章代碼(AID): #1RryHGPo (Braves)