Re: Prospect Smackdown: Sanchez vs. Nippert

看板Diamondbacks作者mittermeyer (眾人脫團我入團XD)時間19年前 (2006/05/28 13:13)推噓1(1推 0噓 0→)

留言1則, 1人參與討論串1/1

※ 引述《Rioss (雷歐斯)》之銘言： http://images.minorleagueball.com/images/admin/anibalsanchez.JPG

http://images.minorleagueball.com/images/admin/nippert.JPG

http://www.minorleagueball.com/story/2006/5/22/125626/336 Per Reader Request, a Prospect Smackdown for Anibal Sanchez and Dustin Nippert 回應之前讀者的請求，新秀比一比：Anibal Sanchez VS Dustin Nippert BACKGROUND and INTANGIBLES 背景和特質 Sanchez: Anibal Sanchez was signed by the Boston Red Sox out of Venezuela in 2001. After two decent campaigns in the Venezuelan Summer League, he hurt his elbow and had to have nerve transposition surgery in 2003. But he returned healthy and effective in '04, emerging as one of Boston's top pitching prospects. The Sox rated him behind Jonathan Papelbon and Jon Lester however, so Sanchez was the guy shipped to Florida in the Josh Beckett trade. Coaches rate him highly for his intelligence on the mound, attitude, and work ethic. Anibal Sanchez2001年在委內瑞拉被波士頓紅襪簽下，在委內瑞拉夏季聯盟投了兩個不錯的球季後，他傷了手肘而必需做韌帶移植手術。但2004年又恢復健康且投出不錯的成績，被視為紅襪農場中的投手新秀之一。紅襪隊把他評價在Jonathan Papelbon與Jon Lester 之後，所以他被打包交易到佛州換來Josh Beckett。教練們對他投球的智慧、態度以及敬業度都有很高的評價。 Nippert: Dustin Nippert was drafted in the 15th round in 2002, from West Virginia University. He pitched brilliantly in his pro debut, and followed that up with a solid '03 season, until hurting his elbow early in 2004 and having to undergo Tommy John surgery. He returned effectively last season, pitched very well in Double-A, regaining his reputation as Arizona's top pitching prospect. He has occasionally had problems with self-confidence, but is highly-regarded for his work ethic and intelligence on the mound. Dustin Nippert2002年從西維吉尼亞大學畢業後，被響尾蛇以第15輪選中。他的職業初登板相當亮眼，接著03年球季也有出色的成績，04年因手肘受傷接受Tommy John手術。上季他恢復到以前的不錯成績，在AA投得很好，重回亞歷桑那投手新秀譜第一位。他有時會自信不足，但是在敬業度及投球智慧上都獲得高度關注。 Advantage: Both pitchers have had serious elbow injuries but came back healthy. Both are regarded as intelligent and hard-working. Sanchez doesn't seem to have had the same self-confidence problems that Nippert has had on occasion, but I don't want to make too much of that, and Nippert (like Sanchez) deserves credit for successfully rehabbing from surgery. Overall this is either even or a slight advantage for Sanchez. 優勢：兩位投手都有手肘爆彈但也都順利清除，兩位也都被認為有投球智慧且努力的投手。Sanchez沒有如Nippert般的自信問題，但我不想在此著墨太多，且Nippert與Sanchez一樣從系統重大錯誤中恢復，也應該得到一些分數。總之這個項目可以說是平手，也可以說是Sanchez稍佔優勢。 PHYSICALITY and TOOLS 身體條件與工具 Sanchez: Sanchez is a righthanded hitter and thrower, born February 27, 1984, listed at 6-0, 180 pounds. His fastball can hit 95 MPH, though he works more comfortably at 90-93. His fastball has very good action and is not a straight pitch. His changeup is excellent, but his breaking ball (sometimes described as a curve, sometimes described as a slider, we can call it a slurve) is erratic and is the main thing he needs to improve. His command and control are excellent, and he does the little things well on the mound. Sanchez右投右打，1984年2月27日生，紀錄上是6呎高，180磅重。他可以投到時速95英哩，但通常在90至93英哩間控制較好。他的快速球有不錯的軌跡且不像是一般直球，變速球非常棒，但他的下墜球（有時被認為是曲球，有時被認為是滑球，我們可以稱它為滑曲球）不穩定，是他最需要改進的地方。他的控球很好，一些投球的小細節也做得很好。 Nippert: Nippert is a righthanded hitter and thrower, born May 6, 1981, listed at 6-7, 215 pounds. Tommy John surgery did not reduce the velocity on his fastball, consistent at 91-94 MPH and sometimes as high as 95-96. His fastball has excellent action low in the strike zone, helping him inhibit extra-base hits. Nippert's curveball is outstanding when it works, but it doesn't always work. His changeup is average. His control is OK but not terrific, and was the main thing he struggled with in his brief major league trial last year. Nippert右投右打，1981年5月6日生，紀錄上是6呎7吋高，215磅重。Tommy John手術未帶走他的球速，游走在91至94英哩間，有時會飆到95或96英哩。快速球在低角度有不錯的軌跡，減低了被打長打的機會。Nippert的曲球非常出色，但就跟陳小刀變張3一樣，不是每次都靈的。控球還可以但還不到出色的階段，也是他去年短暫的大聯盟經驗中，成績不理想的原因之一。 Advantage: Nippert throws a bit harder more consistently. Sanchez has a better changeup, but Nippert has a better breaking ball. Overall I will give Nippert a slight edge. 優勢：Nippert球速稍快，較有續航力。Sanchez的變速球較好，但Nippert有較好的曲球，總體來說我會給Nippert多一點分數。 PERFORMANCE and SKILLS 表現與技巧 Sanchez: Sanchez entered 2006 with a career minor league mark of 22-16, 2.77, with a 396/103 K/BB in 328 innings, with 18 homers allowed out of 239 hits. Sanchez is currently 2-4, 3.99 in nine starts for Double-A Carolina, with a 47/16 K/BB in 47 innings. As stated above, he has a good feel for pitching and changes speeds very well. He is a pitcher, not a thrower. Sanchez在進入2006年球季前，生涯小聯盟成績是22勝16敗，2.77防禦率，328局中有369/ 103的三振/四壞，被打239支安打，其中18支是全壘打。Sanchez本季目前在AA的卡羅萊納9 次先發，繳出2勝4敗，3.99防禦率的成績，47局中的三振/四壞是47/16。根據上述的成績，他的投球球感很好，很會利用速差混淆打者。他是個投手而並非亂丟一通的丟球者。 Nippert: Nippert entered 2006 with a career minor league mark of 20-14, 2.65 in 339 innings, with a 343/123 K/BB ratio, allowing just 10 homers out of 280 hits. Despite his erratic control, he does demonstrate a good feel for pitching and is not just a thrower. He is currently 5-0, 3.51 in six starts for Triple-A Tucson, with a 35/16 K/BB in 41 innings. Nippert進入2006年前的小聯盟生涯成績是20勝14敗，2.65防禦率，339局中有343/123的三振四壞比，被打280支安打中僅10支全壘打。雖然控球不算穩定，他還是展現出投球的球感而並非亂丟。目前在AAA Tucson六次先發中，有5勝0敗，3.51的防禦率，41局中三振四壞比為35/16。 Advantage: Their stats entering this year are very similar. Both have more than a strikeout-per-inning on their resume. Sanchez has shown better control, but Nippert does a better job suppressing the home run. Also note that Nippert has pitched in more difficult environments than Sanchez. Overall I think I will call this even, Sanchez' control advantage being outweighed by Nippert's ability to stop home runs and his good pitching in rough parks. 優勢：進入本季前，他們的數據十分相似。他們都有一局一K的實績。Sanchez有較佳的控球，但Nippert有效的降低被全壘打數，還有值得注意的地方是Nippert所處的聯盟環境較為惡劣。總體而言這個項目他們還是平手，Sanchez的控球優勢被Nippert的低全壘打率及身處的聯盟所扯平。 PROJECTION 未來預됊見Sanchez: Sanchez is 22 years old. His fastball isn't projected to get much faster than it already is, due to his size. Most see him as developing into a potential number two or three starter at the major league level. Possible comparison: the current version of Javier Vazquez?. Sanchez現年22歲，因為身材，他的快速球被預測不會再變得更快，多數的預測認為他會是個二或三號先發。可能會長成現在版本的Javier Vazquez。 Nippert: Nippert is 25, and as such he has less classic projection than Sanchez due to the difference in years. However, if he can improve his command a bit more, his physical upside may be higher, even if he has less time left to reach that upside. Possible comparison: Darryl Kile with fewer home runs allowed? Nippert目前25歲，因為年齡的差異，他少被拿來與大聯盟球員比較。然而，如果他的控球能進步，也許他還會再突破體能上限，雖然他已經沒多少時間了。可能會長成被打較少全壘打的Darryl Kile。 Advantage: I don't think either pitcher projects as a number one starter, at least not consistently, but both should be solid 2-3 guys. 優勢：我不認為他們會成為一號先發，至少在續航力方面，但他們會成為好的2、3號。 SUMMARY 摘要 Nippert and Sanchez aren't guys that you normally pare together in your mind, but as you can see they compare pretty well together. Both are good examples of Grade B+ starting pitching prospects. I rate Sanchez a slight advantage in intangibles, with Nippert having the edge in physicality and tools. They are even in performance/skills, and even overall in projection. Overall I think I would rather have Nippert....the lack of home runs really intrigues me....but both of them are fine prospects. 一般來說，你不會把他們兩個相提並論，但比較起來他們還滿相近的。他們兩個都是不錯的B+等級新秀，我在特質方面給了Sanchez優勢，Nippert在體能及工具方面稍好一些，表現及技能方面兩人平手，總和成績也是平手。最後我還是會給Nippert一勝，因為低全壘打的能力實在太令我感興趣了，但他們兩個都是好的新秀。 -- ════招══生══中══[ 新世紀台灣聯合國學苑 ]══招══生══中════ ☆ 主辦單位：財團法人台灣新世紀文教基金會時間：2006年7月3～7日（5天4夜） ★ ★ 詳情請進入-http://www.taiwanncf.org.tw/ ☆ ☆ 　　電話：(02)2570-8311　 ..........................................★ ★☆★ 傳真：(02)2578-9673　　　　　　　★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆★☆ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.136.192.32