PTT體育區 / MLB (美國職棒/大聯盟)

Project Prospect Top 100 Prospect

看板MLB (美國職棒/大聯盟)作者 (碧潭的逃生者)時間14年前 (2011/02/08 14:04), 編輯推噓29(29推 0噓 24→)
留言53則, 28人參與, 最新討論串1/1
http://projectprospect.com/article/2011/02/07/2011-top-100-prospect-list Outcome Grade Value Hall-of-Fame A+ 10 Superstar A 9 Annual all-star A- 8 All-star B+ 7 Well-above-average regular B 6 Slightly-above-average regular B- 5 Average regular C+/C 4 Below-average regular C- 3 Bench player or reliever D+ 2 Bench player or reliever (short career) D 1 Minor league depth or injury ruins career D-/F 0 Rk Player Pos Age Org Lvl Ceiling Floor Risk 1 Bryce Harper RF 18.3 WAS n/a 9(A) 4(C) High 2 Mike Trout CF 19.5 LAA A+ 8(A-) 5(B-) Moderate 3 Jesus Montero DH/C 21.2 NYY AAA 8(A-) 4(C+/C) Moderate 4 Dustin Ackley 2B 23.0 SEA AAA 6(B) 4(C+/C) Low 5 Eric Hosmer 1B 21.2 KC AA 7(B+) 4(C+/C) Moderate 6 Wil Myers RF 20.2 KC A+ 7(B+) 4(C+/C) Moderate 7 Brandon Belt 1B 22.8 SF AAA 7(B+) 4(C+/C) Moderate 8 Domonic Brown RF 23.4 PHI MLB 7(B+) 3(C-) Moderate 9 Shelby Miller RHP 20.3 STL A 8(A-) 4(C+/C) Moderate 10 Wilin Rosario C 22.0 COL AA 7(B+) 1(D) High 11 Jarrod Parker RHP 22.2 ARI AA 8(A-) 1(D) Very high 12 Freddie Freeman 1B 21.4 ATL MLB 6(B) 4(C+/C) Low 13 Jameson Taillon RHP 19.2 PIT n/a 8(A-) 1(D) Very high 14 Matt Moore LHP 21.6 TB A+ 7(B+) 3(C-) Moderate 15 Yonder Alonso 1B 23.8 CIN MLB 5(B-) 4(C+/C) Very low 16 Mike Moustakas 3B 22.4 KC AAA 6(B) 3(C-) Moderate 17 Desmond Jennings CF 24.3 TB MLB 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 18 Zach Britton LHP 23.1 BAL AAA 7(B+) 1(D) High 19 Jeremy Hellickson RHP 23.8 TB MLB 7(B+) 1(D) High 20 John Lamb LHP 20.6 KC AA 7(B+) 3(C-) Moderate 21 Randall Delgado RHP 21.0 ATL AA 6(B) 3(C-) Moderate 22 Julio Teheran RHP 20.0 ATL AA 7(B+) 1(D) High 23 Aroldis Chapman LHP 22.9 CIN MLB 8(A-) 2(D+) High 24 Devin Mesoraco C 22.6 CIN AAA 6(B) 3(D+) Moderate 25 Lonnie Chisenhall 3B 22.3 CLE AA 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 26 Jaff Decker LF 21.0 SD A+ 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 27 Manny Machado SS 18.6 BAL SS 7(B+) 2(D+) High 28 Jason Kipnis 2B 23.9 CLE AA 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 29 Jose Iglesias SS 21.1 BOS AA 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 30 Mike Minor LHP 23.1 ATL MLB 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 31 Martin Perez LHP 19.9 TEX AA 7(B+) 1(D) High 32 Nick Castellanos 3B 18.9 DET R 6(B) 2(D+) Moderate 33 Nick Weglarz LF 23.1 CLE AAA 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 34 Manny Banuelos LHP 19.9 NYY AA 6(B) 1(D) High 35 Kyle Drabek RHP 23.2 TOR MLB 6(B) 1(D) High 36 Casey Kelly RHP 21.3 SD AA 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 37 Jonathan Singleton 1B 19.4 PHI A 6(B) 2(D+) Moderate 38 Anthony Rizzo 1B 21.5 SD AA 6(B) 2(D+) Moderate 39 Jordan Lyles RHP 20.3 HOU AAA 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 40 Simon Castro RHP 22.8 SD AAA 6(B) 1(D) High 41 Travis d'Arnaud C 22.0 TOR A+ 5(B-) 3(C-) Low 42 Reese Havens 2B 24.3 NYM AA 6(B) 2(D+) Moderate 43 Aaron Hicks CF 21.4 MIN A 6(B) 1(D) High 44 Nick Franklin 2B 19.9 SEA AA 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 45 Zack Wheeler RHP 20.7 SF A 7(B+) 1(D) High 46 Alex White RHP 22.4 CLE AA 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 47 Zach Lee RHP 19.4 LAD n/a 7(B+) 0(D-) Very high 48 Matt Harvey RHP 21.9 NYM n/a 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 49 Tony Sanchez C 22.7 PIT A+ 4(C+/C) 3(C-) Very low 50 Derek Norris C 22.0 WAS A+ 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 51 Jurickson Profar SS 18.0 TEX SS 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 52 Adeiny Hechevarria SS 21.8 TOR AA 6(B) 1(D) High 53 Fernando Martinez RF 22.3 NYM MLB 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 54 Mike Montgomery LHP 21.6 KC AA 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 55 Jacob Turner RHP 19.7 DET A+ 6(B) 1(D) High 56 Michael Pineda RHP 22.1 SEA AAA 7(B+) 0(D-) Very high 57 Brent Morel 3B 23.8 CHW MLB 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 58 Yasmani Grandal C 22.3 CIN R 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 59 Brett Jackson CF 22.5 CHC AA 4(C+/C) 3(C-) Very low 60 Bobby Borchering 3B 20.3 ARI A 6(B) 1(D) High 61 Kyle Gibson RHP 23.3 MIN AAA 6(B) 0(D-) High 62 James Darnell 3B 24.1 SD AA 4(C+/C) 3(C-) Very low 63 Drew Cumberland SS 22.1 SD AA 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 64 Tyler Matzek LHP 20.3 COL A 7(B+) 0(D-) Very high 65 Alexi Amarista 2B 21.8 LAA AAA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 66 Jean Segura 2B 20.9 LAA A 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 67 Matt Dominguez 3B 21.4 FLA AA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 68 Tanner Scheppers RHP 24.1 TEX AAA 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 69 Josh Sale OF 19.6 TB n/a 6(B) 1(D) High 70 Tyler Skaggs LHP 19.6 ARI A 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 71 Jake Odorizzi RHP 20.9 KC A 5(B-) 2(D+) Moderate 72 Anthony Ranaudo RHP 21.4 BOS n/a 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 73 Gary Sanchez C 19.0 NYY SS 6(B) 1(D) High 74 Hank Conger C 23.0 LAA AAA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 75 Chris Sale LHP 21.9 CHW MLB 6(B) 0(D-) High 76 Danny Espinosa SS 23.8 WAS MLB 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 77 Dayan Viciedo 1B 21.9 CHW MLB 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 78 Christian Colon SS 21.7 KC A+ 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 79 Josh Spence RHP 23.0 SD n/a 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 80 Craig Kimbrel RHP 22.7 ATL MLB 4(C+/C) 1(D) Moderate 81 Adrian Salcedo RHP 19.8 MIN A+ 6(B) 0(D-) High 82 Hector Gomez SS 20.3 COL AA 5(B-) 0(D-) High 83 Jenrry Mejia RHP 21.3 NYM MLB 4(C+/C) 1(D) Moderate 84 Hak-Ju Lee SS 20.9 TB A 4(C+/C) 1(D) Moderate 85 Austin Romine C 22.2 NYY AA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 86 Chris Carter 1B 24.1 OAK MLB 4(C+/C) 1(D) Moderate 87 Sammy Solis LHP 22.5 WAS A 5(B-) 0(D-) High 88 Blake Tekotte CF 23.7 SD AA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 89 Tyler Postornicky SS 21.2 ATL AA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 90 Johnny Giavotella 2B 22.9 KC AA 4(C+/C) 1(D) Moderate 91 Tyler Chatwood RHP 21.1 LAA AAA 5(B-) 1(D) Moderate 92 Steve Lombardozzi 2B 22.4 WAS AA 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 93 Charlie Blackmon CF 24.6 COL AA 3(C-) 2(D+) Very low 94 Brad Emaus 3B 24.9 NYM AAA 3(C-) 2(D+) Very low 95 Yamaico Navarro 3B 23.3 BOS MLB 3(C-) 2(D+) Very low 96 David Adams 2B 23.7 NYY AA 3(C-) 2(D+) Very low 97 Anthony Gose CF 20.5 TOR A+ 4(C+/C) 2(D+) Low 98 Miguel Sano 3B 17.7 MIN R 5(B-) 0(D-) High 99 Drew Pomeranz LHP 22.2 CLE n/a 4(C+/C) 0(D-) Moderate 100 Wilmer Flores SS 19.5 NYM A+ 4(C+/C) 1(D+) Moderate -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 59.112.208.247
推
02/08 14:06, , 1F
LV裡面的SS是什麼意思阿@_@
02/08 14:06, 1F
推
02/08 14:11, , 2F
Hellboy狂跌欸XDDDDDD
02/08 14:11, 2F
推
02/08 14:12, , 3F
SS是short season
02/08 14:12, 3F
→
02/08 14:12, , 4F
狂跌是指什麼狂跌? 跟去年比嗎?
02/08 14:12, 4F
推
02/08 14:14, , 5F
之前看其他的Prospect 以前他還排滿前面的阿 至少TB第一XD
02/08 14:14, 5F
→
02/08 14:14, , 6F
現在被超車
02/08 14:14, 6F
推
02/08 14:17, , 7F
SS代表short season 短期1A的意思
02/08 14:17, 7F
→
02/08 14:18, , 8F
BP不是另一家嗎
02/08 14:18, 8F
推
02/08 14:22, , 9F
請問 這邊的floor 是指現在的程度嗎?
02/08 14:22, 9F
推
02/08 14:23, , 10F
BP通常是指baseball prospectus
02/08 14:23, 10F
→
02/08 14:25, , 11F
那不叫狂跌吧,各家排法著重的點本來就不太一樣
02/08 14:25, 11F
→
02/08 14:28, , 12F
hellboy天花板只有Well-above-average的確是跌啊
02/08 14:28, 12F
→
02/08 14:29, , 13F
看錯列-_-
02/08 14:29, 13F
※ 編輯: lovejeely 來自: 59.112.208.247 (02/08 14:55)
→
02/08 14:57, , 14F
標題打錯，已修正來源網址資料
02/08 14:57, 14F
推
02/08 15:26, , 15F
floor應該是至少可以這樣的意思吧
02/08 15:26, 15F
推
02/08 15:32, , 16F
當初Wieters的天花板是不是10 XD
02/08 15:32, 16F
推
02/08 15:39, , 17F
Harper為什麼是High啊？
02/08 15:39, 17F
推
02/08 15:43, , 18F
Adam Foster不給Hellboy高排名是因為肩傷的關係
02/08 15:43, 18F
→
02/08 15:43, , 19F
認為過去有肩傷的投手會比較麻煩
02/08 15:43, 19F
→
02/08 15:45, , 20F
Pineda這麼低也是因為手肘受過傷
02/08 15:45, 20F
推
02/08 15:46, , 21F
Harper 年紀太小 + 連MiLB都還沒打
02/08 15:46, 21F
推
02/08 15:49, , 22F
ceiling和floor差太多就會被視為high risk
02/08 15:49, 22F
→
02/08 15:50, , 23F
我比較想知道過去有哪些球員的ceiling是10?
02/08 15:50, 23F
推
02/08 15:51, , 24F
David Adams排的進Top 100? o.0
02/08 15:51, 24F
→
02/08 15:55, , 25F
Pujos?
02/08 15:55, 25F
推
02/08 16:00, , 26F
有人如果能直接被列在A+真的就很猛XD
02/08 16:00, 26F
→
02/08 16:00, , 27F
剛起步就被預期要是HOF...很猛又不可能受傷
02/08 16:00, 27F
※ lovejeely:轉錄至看板 Mariners 02/08 16:04
推
02/08 17:05, , 28F
覺得9(Super star)應該比10(名人堂)強吧
02/08 17:05, 28F
→
02/08 17:13, , 29F
樓上的觀念好特別
02/08 17:13, 29F
推
02/08 17:24, , 30F
Freeman跟Jennings的Ceiling只有6跟5喔...
02/08 17:24, 30F
推
02/08 17:31, , 31F
想知道之前有沒有人prospect時就列為A+的
02/08 17:31, 31F
推
02/08 17:38, , 32F
Casey Kelly和Jennings的天花板比想像中的低...
02/08 17:38, 32F
推
02/08 17:43, , 33F
印象中好像沒看過A+ 天才小史也才A Justin Upton跟
02/08 17:43, 33F
→
02/08 17:43, , 34F
A Rod不知如何
02/08 17:43, 34F
推
02/08 17:49, , 35F
HOF > superstar
02/08 17:49, 35F
推
02/08 19:25, , 36F
我倒覺得superster>HOF 看看Bonds、McGwire...etc
02/08 19:25, 36F
推
02/08 19:30, , 37F
下面請開始戰 *****
02/08 19:30, 37F
推
02/08 19:36, , 38F
這是我第一份看到把Randell Delgado排的比Teharan高的
02/08 19:36, 38F
→
02/08 19:37, , 39F
兩個人今年同時從high-A到AA的適應能力表現,數據,年紀
02/08 19:37, 39F
→
02/08 19:37, , 40F
應該是Teharan完勝...不知道為啥給Delgado比較高的排名
02/08 19:37, 40F
→
02/08 19:38, , 41F
即使只是前後的差距..因為在我的感覺兩個人level有差
02/08 19:38, 41F
→
02/08 19:39, , 42F
拍謝兩個名子都錯了Randall & Teheran才對
02/08 19:39, 42F
→
02/08 19:40, , 43F
沒有人F 可是很多高風險的都是"injury ruins career"吧
02/08 19:40, 43F
→
02/08 19:42, , 44F
我覺得mike minor就夠好了..斧頭的投手新秀真是深不可測..
02/08 19:42, 44F
推
02/08 19:59, , 45F
因為排名的人認為Teheran的投球機制會限制他在牛棚
02/08 19:59, 45F
→
02/08 19:59, , 46F
所以才比Delgado低
02/08 19:59, 46F
推
02/08 20:56, , 47F
謝謝幾樓的解答^^
02/08 20:56, 47F
推
02/09 06:04, , 48F
這樣看來 Trout floor是這篇評價最好的...
02/09 06:04, 48F
推
02/09 11:00, , 49F
講到Trout 這支是洋基的籤補償給天使選到的
02/09 11:00, 49F
→
02/09 11:00, , 50F
反倒是童年的CC 釀酒人得到的補償順位就差非常多了 XD
02/09 11:00, 50F
→
02/09 11:00, , 51F
難怪九人GM要出門哭哭XD
02/09 11:00, 51F
推
02/09 15:42, , 52F
沒有釀酒人的新秀.....
02/09 15:42, 52F
→
02/10 08:18, , 53F
借轉藍鳥板
02/10 08:18, 53F
※ MickJan:轉錄至看板 Blue_Jays 02/10 08:18
‣ 更多 lovejeely 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1DKDprAx (MLB)
MLB 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT體育區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 lovejeely 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1DKDprAx (MLB)