[情報] 為何優秀女子選手缺乏穩定性?

看板Tennis (網球)作者 (費拔不在很寂寞)時間16年前 (2010/07/14 00:53), 編輯推噓46(47164)
留言112則, 38人參與, 最新討論串1/1
此篇文章發表於4月號的Tennis Life 來自Patrick Mouratoglou的專業分析 全文: In tournament after tournament,we witness a bloodletting as the best woman players in the world get knocked out in the early rounds, Dinara Safina,Elena Dementieva,Nadia Petrova,Caroline Wozniacki, Venus Williams,Vera Zvonareva....the lists goes on. 我們經由一場接著一場的比賽,見證了許多優秀女選手紛紛於前幾輪賽事遭到淘汰, 莎妹、戴娃、派娃、Woz妹、大威、Z娃....等,族繁不及備載。 Yes,the best players in the world will experience ups and downs throughout the year- a phenomenon that everyone notices but few can explain. Often,you'll hear people say that this is because the average level of play in the woman's game is low,and that the best players never really dominate, so that anybody can win or lose at any time. 沒錯,有種世界優秀的女網選手們的狀態,一整年下來時好時壞的感覺,每個人都感受 的到但能解釋這現象的卻寥寥無幾。 你會聽到人們說這是因為,女網的平均水準低,近年從沒有選手真的主宰過女子網壇, 所以即使她們哪天會贏或輸都不意外。 But this argument needs to be clarified;it isn't enough to explain good- results during some weeks or months,then horrible results in others,I think this inconsistency is due essentially to a couple of things. 但這項議論需要被澄清,它不足以說明選手們在某星期或當月取得佳績,但又在另一場 賽事表現的很糟糕,我認為這不一致性有幾個原因。 Several top-10 players have similar qualities:the will,the determination, the dedication.They are devoted,hard workers,and they develop very intense games.Safina,Dementieva,Wozniacki,Zvonareva,Victoria Azarenka,and Jelena - Jankovic are among these players.They give very few points away,they fight "to the death",they seem to never tire,and they impose their intense rhythm in rallies. 多數頂尖選手有著相似的特質,她們意志堅強、有果斷力、肯奉獻且富有熱忱地努力著, 她們的比賽時常充滿張力。像莎妹、戴娃、Woz妹、Z娃、Aza妹,還有JJ都是這類型的選手 。她們很少讓關鍵分溜走,奮戰精神無以復加,好像從不覺得疲累,在對抽時主導強力的 節奏。 However,none of them have the real weapons to make the difference.And that's unfortunate because they devote so much energy and desire to their games. The problem is,they don't spend this time developing a "weapon". 然而,她們卻沒有人有一項真正的武器,能讓比賽顯得不同。那很令人遺憾,因為她們 為比賽奉獻如此多的能量和企圖心。真正的問題是,她們卻沒花些時間培養屬於自己的 武器。 Scheduling Problems  On the other hand some players,like Venus and Serena Williams and Maria - Sharapova,have these harmful shots that allow them to save themselves - physically,to have to work less for points,and to force a win on days things may not otherwise be going their way.For these players,it is almost an obligation to be mentally fresh and at perfect physical conditioning in order to find a way to win. 換句話說有些選手,像是大威和小威以及莎娃,具有強大破壞力的抽擊,得以讓她們 完全地在比賽中生存下來,為了必須減輕場上負擔,並在每場比賽中獲得勝利,或許 不會有其他方法了。對這些選手而言,這幾乎是為了保持良好的身心狀況,去取得勝 利的職責所在了。 At certain times of the year,these players are physically and mentally fresh. And they often link together their best results in a series of wins. For some of them,like Azarenka,Safina and Dementieva,generally this happens earlier in the year.The problem,though,is that these types of players don't handle their schedules properly and consider their periods of rest and training.This means that even though they come back fresh and in shape,they don't stay that way. 一年之中某些時候,這些選手的身心處在不錯的狀況,她們常趁這時去取得一連串的 勝利和很好的賽果,對於像Aza妹、莎妹和戴娃來說,大都發生在一年的賽季開始不久時。 問題是這類型的選手,不會顧慮到她們休息、訓練的期間去安排賽程。 這意味著,就算她們健康而且狀況良好地回來,也無法持續太久。 These players end up playing more tournaments than others on pro tours,and they don't respect their needed resting periods.They are often afraid of " losing their edge" or "losing the rhythm",and that's compounded because they know they aren't superior to the rest of the players on tour. 結果這些選手總是比其他人多打了許多賽事,卻忽略有時她們也需要休息的事實。 她們常害怕會因此手感遲鈍或是跟不上場上的節奏,這是她們不好好規畫休息期間 的影響。 So what do they do? They make the wrong choice,and they play too much.Their thinking is,"As long as I'm winning,let's keep playing tournaments.If I lose ,we need to play again quickly so we can start all over" Since their games forces them to always give their maximum in every single point of the match,they end up wearing themselves out.Then,instead of sustained periods of winning tennis,they have long periods of losing tennis. 所以她們該怎麼做呢?她們做了錯誤的選擇,參加過多的比賽。她們想著"只要我贏了, 就繼續下一個比賽。如果我輸了,我需要趕快振作然後重新開始。" 自從她們開始強迫自己,在比賽中,盡最大努力爭取每一分,她們最終會筋疲力盡,然後 反而無法發揮穩定的戰力,於是開始輸球。 以下是作者的建議: What You Can Do What lesson can young players learn from this? It's important to invest early in developing one or two very strong shots(if possible,the serve and the return ).When you work hard and are focused,you gain an exceptional advantage over other players.Now,add to that by spending the time you need to develop a weapon .It will pay off for you down the road. 從這當中年輕選手們學到了些什麼?重要的是要發展出一兩個強勁的抽擊(如果可能, 也順便練練發球和接發)。當你努力且保持集中,你會得到那項超越其他選手的優勢。 現在你需要花點時間去發展一項武器。而它會在你狀況不佳時給予妳回報。 Also pay attention to your tournament schedule.In that way,you need to consider your style of play,so you know when you need to rest or take some times to regroup,rather than just forging ahead and playing more and more,even though your game is suffering. 同時要對賽程表用點心。在那種情形下,你需要考量你的球風,你才知道你何時你該休息 或是花些時間思考一下,總比傻傻地前進且瘋狂參賽要來得強,即使是狀態不好時也應如 此。 Confidence is built up by victories.A few weeks of bad results can quickly ruin the confidence that you gained in earlier weeks.But a well-managed schedule will allow you to win and keep building your confidence. 信心是建立在贏球上。短短幾星期的壞賽果能迅速地毀掉,你早先建立的信心。但是有效 作賽程規畫,將會讓你步向勝利且維持你得來不易的信心。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.39.185.16

07/14 00:57, , 1F
Scheduling Problems的第二段應該是說在每年賽季的早期
07/14 00:57, 1F

07/14 00:57, , 2F
不是早年生涯
07/14 00:57, 2F

07/14 00:59, , 3F
這篇文章講的真不錯 很多年輕選手真的該想想如何排賽程
07/14 00:59, 3F

07/14 00:59, , 4F
不僅僅是信心毀掉的問題 也是為了避免受傷或身心疲乏
07/14 00:59, 4F

07/14 01:00, , 5F
沒花時間培養武器? 那要怎樣的程度才算是武器?
07/14 01:00, 5F

07/14 01:02, , 6F
哇~看的好快 感謝指正!
07/14 01:02, 6F

07/14 01:05, , 7F
武器大概像是Roddick的發球 Gonzalez Nadal的正手之類的~
07/14 01:05, 7F

07/14 01:08, , 8F
我的問題點在於 男子都知道要發展自己的武器 女子選手怎麼
07/14 01:08, 8F

07/14 01:08, , 9F
可能不會去發展自己的武器?有這種可能嗎
07/14 01:08, 9F

07/14 01:09, , 10F
女網的話大概像...海寧的反拍、小威的發球、Sam的正拍
07/14 01:09, 10F

07/14 01:09, , 11F
所以我不相信女子選手不會去發展自己的武器 只是...
07/14 01:09, 11F

07/14 01:09, , 12F
Sam的正拍武器比起前兩者好像會比較因場地受限@@
07/14 01:09, 12F

07/14 01:12, , 13F
相較於前面兩者的確穩定度較低 但還是很有殺傷力
07/14 01:12, 13F

07/14 01:13, , 14F
戴娃的雙誤是別人的武器XD
07/14 01:13, 14F

07/14 01:13, , 15F
我覺得安排賽事方面henin以前做得很好 但是溫網前一週除外XD
07/14 01:13, 15F

07/14 01:15, , 16F
很多Top30~50左右的男選手也缺乏Lethal weapon
07/14 01:15, 16F

07/14 01:15, , 17F
戴娃要是發球正常 也不會那麼悲情了
07/14 01:15, 17F

07/14 01:16, , 18F
我個人傾向是練不起來 請問誰不知道要把武器練起來呢?
07/14 01:16, 18F

07/14 01:16, , 19F
我覺得Lu就是,如果Lu有更好的發球或正手,只要得之其一,我
07/14 01:16, 19F

07/14 01:16, , 20F
戴娃經典名句:No, I can't serve...(淚眼汪汪)
07/14 01:16, 20F

07/14 01:17, , 21F
想排名一定能再往前;但我同意D兄說的,不是想練就練得起來
07/14 01:17, 21F

07/14 01:17, , 22F
對阿戴娃的武器是啥? 底線嗎
07/14 01:17, 22F

07/14 01:19, , 23F
Djo的武器是拍球數十下把對手接球專注力拍掉 & 深 呼 吸~~
07/14 01:19, 23F

07/14 01:20, , 24F
戴娃最大的武器應該是接發球了 但這個非常吃天份
07/14 01:20, 24F

07/14 01:20, , 25F
戴娃的劇本才是讓對手鬆懈的秘密武器...
07/14 01:20, 25F

07/14 01:21, , 26F
我前幾天正好讀到去年8月號的TENNIS也是討論這個問題orz
07/14 01:21, 26F

07/14 01:23, , 27F
結論跟這篇有點像 不過Tennis雜誌用的字眼是"女網缺乏特性"
07/14 01:23, 27F

07/14 01:23, , 28F
意思是大家打法都差不多(強力網球 強力網球 還是強力網球)
07/14 01:23, 28F

07/14 01:24, , 29F
問題是不這麼打又不行(近年來只有一個打法較不同的Henin)
07/14 01:24, 29F

07/14 01:26, , 30F
重點在於 不強力網球的前提是 要先能擋住強力網球
07/14 01:26, 30F

07/14 01:26, , 31F
反覆 再加上賽事頻繁(為了成績&錢) 最後很多年輕選手就受不
07/14 01:26, 31F

07/14 01:27, , 32F
了(不管是身心上) 才會有一堆曇花一現的女網選手
07/14 01:27, 32F

07/14 01:30, , 33F
不過文章好像還是無解(就只能祈禱出個身心健全的女金剛)
07/14 01:30, 33F

07/14 01:31, , 34F
我不覺得henin不算強力網球 只是他部份技術表現很成熟
07/14 01:31, 34F

07/14 01:33, , 35F
我覺得可能要等威廉斯姊妹退休才有改變的可能...
07/14 01:33, 35F

07/14 01:41, , 36F
還有一個 訓練裡 難訓練也常忽略的 是選手的情緒心理控管
07/14 01:41, 36F

07/14 01:42, , 37F
這個部份 男心理素質普遍比女堅強太多
07/14 01:42, 37F

07/14 01:46, , 38F
選手的身心發展不全 要威廉斯退休才能改變?@@
07/14 01:46, 38F

07/14 02:01, , 39F
非常同意Kirk大第一句
07/14 02:01, 39F
還有 33 則推文
還有 1 段內文
07/14 15:59, , 73F
看妹是附加價值 沒什麼不好
07/14 15:59, 73F

07/14 17:17, , 74F
因為有些人只準自己看妹 不準女球迷看帥哥(會酸)
07/14 17:17, 74F

07/14 17:18, , 75F
不過球技才是重點 長相只是加分
07/14 17:18, 75F

07/14 17:29, , 76F
幾乎都帥哥阿 只是不同國不同型(top10那些法國的例外)
07/14 17:29, 76F

07/14 20:21, , 77F
我覺得強力網球比起過去的無聊很多....
07/14 20:21, 77F

07/14 20:47, , 78F
我不覺得幾乎都帥哥......(我女的)
07/14 20:47, 78F

07/14 22:11, , 79F
我會喜歡海寧的原因是因為她的單手反拍實在太犀利了!!!
07/14 22:11, 79F

07/14 22:12, , 80F
這就是一種武器啊!!
07/14 22:12, 80F

07/14 22:12, , 81F
前幾名都還滿帥的阿
07/14 22:12, 81F

07/14 22:17, , 82F
帥不帥見仁見智吧 @@
07/14 22:17, 82F

07/14 23:12, , 83F
講廢話吧 !! 以為都不會有MC來阿,怎每個人都剛好走了
07/14 23:12, 83F

07/14 23:13, , 84F
這樣也叫專業文阿
07/14 23:13, 84F

07/14 23:14, , 85F
我也不覺得女網多正妹,只是人努力專注的時候都有股魅力
07/14 23:14, 85F

07/14 23:15, , 86F
在球場上看起來是男的帥女的美,身材有加分,下了球場後迷
07/14 23:15, 86F

07/14 23:16, , 87F
人的魅力就沒了.所以球迷們還是覺得庫娃在球場上最美.
07/14 23:16, 87F

07/14 23:17, , 88F
樓上說的也是,女性的生理週期對內分泌造成很大的影響
07/14 23:17, 88F

07/14 23:28, , 89F
報您知:現在Top 10沒有法國人,攻擊無效!
07/14 23:28, 89F

07/14 23:50, , 90F
我蠻推l大說的 球場表現真的有加分 而且可能是很大
07/14 23:50, 90F

07/14 23:51, , 91F
場內外感覺會不同 不過想亂入一下XD
07/14 23:51, 91F

07/14 23:52, , 92F
個人默默覺得西方人比東方人有多些優勢 身材和深邃
07/14 23:52, 92F

07/14 23:54, , 93F
臉孔 就算外貌不是很突出 深邃可以掩蓋很多
07/14 23:54, 93F

07/15 00:00, , 94F
突然驚覺WTA會有那個來的問題@@(以前沒有想到...)
07/15 00:00, 94F

07/15 00:00, , 95F
如果剛好撞期的話也太辛苦...
07/15 00:00, 95F

07/15 00:02, , 96F
推l大 其實女網球員很多蠻高壯的 男球員我是真的不覺得帥
07/15 00:02, 96F

07/15 00:02, , 97F
真的很帥的只有一個safin
07/15 00:02, 97F

07/15 00:04, , 98F
MC的問題 我妹是運動員 她是說有重要比賽會先吃藥避掉
07/15 00:04, 98F

07/15 00:04, , 99F
不過網球比賽賽程這麼密集 我不知道她們是怎麼處理就是
07/15 00:04, 99F

07/15 00:12, , 100F
只能說有魅力和長相好看 有時候是兩碼子事 XD
07/15 00:12, 100F

07/15 04:34, , 101F
現在調經技術還滿準確的喔,應該都有事先處理
07/15 04:34, 101F

07/15 12:20, , 102F
調經技術仍無法緩解經期的不適啊......Y
07/15 12:20, 102F

07/16 00:07, , 103F
我記得有藥可以讓經期早點來,不然月經來了怎打比賽= =?
07/16 00:07, 103F

07/16 00:15, , 104F
可是Woz動輒連打六七週XD 那樣如果一直吃藥身體會搞壞吧
07/16 00:15, 104F

07/16 00:18, , 105F
這要看人體質吧 有的人可以沒事照常打 有的人會痛到
07/16 00:18, 105F

07/16 00:18, , 106F
吐或是昏倒
07/16 00:18, 106F

07/20 12:48, , 107F
很簡單~生理還有心理構造不同~
07/20 12:48, 107F

07/20 12:48, , 108F
如果男選手很強又很帥~很多女友跟隨~
07/20 12:48, 108F

07/20 12:54, , 109F
反之~女孩子還是比較依賴另一半~我是說統計上啦
07/20 12:54, 109F

07/21 00:45, , 110F
嗯?有這種統計
07/21 00:45, 110F

07/21 00:48, , 111F
我想P大的意思是男性選手的另一伴愛相隨的比例高,女性選
07/21 00:48, 111F

07/21 00:49, , 112F
手的伴侶會這麼做得相對少吧(張宇和姜山的例子算少數吧)
07/21 00:49, 112F
文章代碼(AID): #1CF9dwZ3 (Tennis)
文章代碼(AID): #1CF9dwZ3 (Tennis)