Re: [問題] 陽大哥是自己煞不住還是被推開?已回收

看板Baseball (棒球)作者x840101 (瘋狂的魂魄)時間8年前 (2016/07/29 23:20)推噓15(16推 1噓 4→)

留言21則, 17人參與討論串2/2 (看更多)

※ 引述《shiwenli (阿爸)》之銘言： : 我個人跑壘經驗，應該是自己身體煞不住， : 離心力讓整個身體偏離壘包， : 可是主播卻說是王勝偉推開的？ : 我是覺得這種容易引起對立的言詞， : 主播要謹慎啦！我猿迷同樣覺得今天陽大哥是煞不住但是印象中好像大聯盟有把跑者推走的爭議於是找到以下爭議 http://goo.gl/OeURzp 找不到影片請高手提供 The eighth Friday might have been the biggest single inning of Mark Canha's professional career to date. The Rule 5 slugger opened it with the A's down 5-0, hitting his third homer to get Oakland on the scoreboard. He brought a seven-run uprising to an end with a single to center that gave the A's some insurance. “Especially with this team, this is the biggest inning yet." Canha said. But the inning wasn't over quite then. Canha stole second base. At least he thought he had until umpire Andy Fletcher ruled that he came off the base and that Elvis Andrus had held the tag. Canha盜二壘，直到二壘審判他離開壘包被貓王觸殺出局 The A's went into a tizzy, believing that Andrus pushed Canha off the base. That's what the replay showed, Andrus getting his glove under Canha's leg and lifting it off the base to the point where Fletcher called the out. 運動家隊認為是貓王把Canha推出去的，重播確實如此，貓王用手套把她的腳從壘包上抬起，造成二壘審Fletcher判出局 "That's exactly what happened." Canha said. And what about the replay? Funny you should ask. Dislodging a base runner from a base is not a play that can be reviewed. 至於重播呢？把跑者推出去是不能適用輔助判決的 “I guess it's not something you can challenge." Canha said. “It doesn't matter, though, because we won the game." Even so, manager Bob Melvin didn't want to talk about the play afterward , saying that replays have consistently gone against the A's this season, and he didn’t want to ruin what was an otherwise nice night. Here's a question, though: If push a player off a base can't be reviewed, why not have your infielders push runners off the base all the time? If no one sees, you can get a quick out. If someone does see, there’s no penalty, the runner just gets to keep the base. 我們可以想到一個問題：既然不能重播把跑者推出壘包的判決，那內野手何不這麼做？如果沒人看到，就能抓到出局數；如果有人看到，也沒有罰則啊！ It may be a rule that the MLB brass might want to alter before too much longer. 去年我比較常看MLB時有聽到主播在討論，不知道今年大聯盟官方是否有解決之道，不過還是可以用這個例子讓大家知道，跑者還是有可能被推出壘包。當然這次應該不是啦！ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.230.12.112 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Baseball/M.1469805623.A.E91.html ※ 編輯: x840101 (36.230.12.112), 07/29/2016 23:23:12

推

coastr29479

07/29 23:23, , 1^F

07/29 23:23, 1^F

推

adam7148

07/29 23:23, , 2^F

07/29 23:23, 2^F

※ 編輯: x840101 (36.230.12.112), 07/29/2016 23:29:15

推

howardq44

07/29 23:27, , 3^F