PTT體育區 / NBA (美國籃球)

[外絮] nba官方證實G6 最後換上Duncan是犯規的已回收

看板NBA (美國籃球)作者 (autumned)時間13年前 (2013/06/20 10:03), 編輯推噓60(96推 36噓 85→)
留言217則, 127人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
如題，前面也有板友提出疑問 的確是犯規的 http://gamedayr.com/gamedayr/tim-duncan-game-6-illegal-substitution/ The NBA dodged a massive bullet after Ray Allen pulled a Jesus Shuttlesworth and saved the Heat’s season with 5.3 seconds remaining in regulation of Game 6. Had future Hall of Famer Tim Duncan been the one to bury a game-winner in those final seconds, the league would have to explain why a player who was not even supposed to be in the game in the first place had just won his Spurs the championship. Ray Allen在正規賽剩下5.3秒時扮演救世主射進了一個三分球並解救了熱火隊... 這也讓NBA逃過了一個大麻煩 要是Duncan最後又投進絕殺球，聯盟大概就得準備解釋: 為什麼一個根本不應該在場上的球員可以幫馬刺贏得勝利? Let’s back up. What are we talking about? ? ?? 現在到底是在講啥? After Allen hit his series and season-saving three for Miami, the officials stopped the game in order to check out the tape. The refs were looking to make sure Allen’s feet were both behind the three-point line. 當Allen投進了關鍵的三分後 裁判暫停了比賽去看重播以確認Allen的腳 沒有踩線. Coach Gregg Popovich’s Spurs were out of timeouts at the time. The break in action gave him an opportunity to at least talk to his players, if not draw something up. Popovich其實已經沒有暫停了...這個空檔剛好可以讓他跟他的球員談談 Pop substituted Duncan, which was an illegal move. Because there was no foul or timeout called, the same five players that walked off the court to wait were the same five who were supposed to walk back on. 但是Pop把Duncan換上去是不行的啊!!!! 因為沒有犯規或是暫停的發生， 走下場的五名球員一定要和回到場上的五名球員一樣， 一個都不能改 But such was not the case, and the NBA confirmed its mistake on Wednesday. 不過這種事情就是發生了，NBA今天也承認了他們的失誤 Nuts, indeed. The substitution should have been called a technical foul, which should have resulted in Miami foul shots. Such a situation would have presumably resulted in Ray Allen winning the game for the Heat. 真的很囧。當時這個換人應該要判馬刺一個T的(Duncan for T!!!!!!!!!!) 熱火要罰一球.... 而這很有可能讓熱火直接帶走勝利....Ray Allen變成讓熱火直接獲勝的大功臣 Conversely, if Duncan (or any other Spurs player for that matter) had hit a shot to win the game, they would have done all the celebrating in the world — only to have to re-play the final five seconds of the game at a later date. 反過來說 要是Duncan(或馬刺任何人) 投進任何一球「贏得勝利」，他們和各地的球迷大概已經瘋狂的在慶祝勝利.... 不過當這個違規被發現之後，他們事後還是得回來重打G6最後五秒鐘-_- Seriously. The shot would have been protested by the Heat, and an expedited ruling on the part of commissioner David Stern would have likely forced the two teams to take the court, totally cold, with seconds remaining in Game 6 of the Finals. Remember, the Spurs would have already celebrated winning the NBA title, as any game-winning shot with Duncan on the floor at that point would have given San Antonio four wins for the series. 我是認真的，就算馬刺慶祝都慶祝完了，熱火還是可能提出抗議， Stern很可能命令兩隊回去重打G6的最後關頭.... (這真的蠻有可能發生的..任何馬刺球員進球都可能為馬刺贏得總冠軍) Luckily, the NBA does not have to worry about any of the this. The Spurs did not score, the Heat won, 103-100, in an epic overtime clash, and now both are gearing up for what promises to be a Game 7 for the ages. 算是幸運吧，NBA不需要為這煩惱了,因為熱火最後贏了 Although we just have to say: While the Thursday Game 7 is going to be nuts, doing over Game 6 would have really made for some viewing for the ages. 不管G7打的怎樣，G6就算在很久以後也是會被拿出來檢視的案例了 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.168.87.172
→
06/20 10:04, , 1F
馬刺果然是老油條...
06/20 10:04, 1F
推
06/20 10:04, , 2F
原來裁判的暫停不能換人 0.0 以為NBA規則都比較鬆說
06/20 10:04, 2F
推
06/20 10:05, , 3F
pop就喜歡找旁門左道
06/20 10:05, 3F
→
06/20 10:05, , 4F
Pop表示
06/20 10:05, 4F
推
06/20 10:05, , 5F
簡言之 雷槍救了熱火
06/20 10:05, 5F
推
06/20 10:06, , 6F
救了馬刺吧，封王爽半天跟你說不算...
06/20 10:06, 6F
→
06/20 10:06, , 7F
POP這超級老狐狸.......
06/20 10:06, 7F
推
06/20 10:07, , 8F
POPO:被發現了
06/20 10:07, 8F
推
06/20 10:07, , 9F
其實POPO超不爽這暫停的..
06/20 10:07, 9F
推
06/20 10:07, , 10F
XDD
06/20 10:07, 10F
推
06/20 10:08, , 11F
popo超會鑽...
06/20 10:08, 11F
噓
06/20 10:08, , 12F
這種垃圾步 還敢跟人說黑哨 有趣
06/20 10:08, 12F
推
06/20 10:08, , 13F
雷槍沒進球-> 裁判就不會確認是否為三分 ->馬刺就不
06/20 10:08, 13F
推
06/20 10:08, , 14F
話說回來，就算不論馬刺是否有意，當下裁判和熱火都
06/20 10:08, 14F
推
06/20 10:08, , 15F
救了大家
06/20 10:08, 15F
→
06/20 10:08, , 16F
沒注意到也挺扯的。
06/20 10:08, 16F
推
06/20 10:09, , 17F
XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
06/20 10:09, 17F
→
06/20 10:09, , 18F
真是太給pop面子 否則算犯規直接罰球 馬刺根本沒機會
06/20 10:09, 18F
推
06/20 10:09, , 19F
游牧民族：熱火超黑的
06/20 10:09, 19F
→
06/20 10:09, , 20F
會有鄧肯上場的機會 -> 馬刺封王 所以就了熱火無誤
06/20 10:09, 20F
→
06/20 10:09, , 21F
還玩最後一波進攻
06/20 10:09, 21F
推
06/20 10:09, , 22F
還有記錄組在幹嘛，他說換就傻傻讓他換XD
06/20 10:09, 22F
推
06/20 10:09, , 23F
XDDD
06/20 10:09, 23F
推
06/20 10:10, , 24F
就算罰球 馬刺還是有最後一次機會 而且這樣輸球
06/20 10:10, 24F
推
06/20 10:10, , 25F
POPO:都輸了啊 不然是要怎樣?
06/20 10:10, 25F
推
06/20 10:10, , 26F
其實去馬刺板 刺迷都沒什麼再酸黑哨 真正再酸的應該
06/20 10:10, 26F
→
06/20 10:10, , 27F
爭議性會更高...
06/20 10:10, 27F
→
06/20 10:10, , 28F
沒總冠軍賽打的__迷
06/20 10:10, 28F
→
06/20 10:10, , 29F
裁判有比馬刺黑?
06/20 10:10, 29F
推
06/20 10:10, , 30F
還好熱火贏球，這事情就不重要了，只是一個插曲
06/20 10:10, 30F
→
06/20 10:11, , 31F
對耶 就覺得奇怪怎TD又上來了
06/20 10:11, 31F
→
06/20 10:11, , 32F
我還是比較喜歡目前的結局
06/20 10:11, 32F
推
06/20 10:11, , 33F
問一下 罰完被吹T這球後 球權算誰的?
06/20 10:11, 33F
推
06/20 10:11, , 34F
結果根本不應該打延長，TD吃T後雷槍罰球一分取勝
06/20 10:11, 34F
推
06/20 10:12, , 35F
超黑!!!
06/20 10:12, 35F
→
06/20 10:12, , 36F
直接罰球馬刺不會沒機會啊，因為還有五秒
06/20 10:12, 36F
噓
06/20 10:12, , 37F
髒馬刺
06/20 10:12, 37F
推
06/20 10:12, , 38F
TD又一傳說，暫停後上場吃T
06/20 10:12, 38F
→
06/20 10:12, , 39F
我以為多半凍結時間都可以換人lol
06/20 10:12, 39F
還有 138 則推文
噓
06/20 12:11, , 178F
黑馬 爛死
06/20 12:11, 178F
推
06/20 12:13, , 179F
馬刺可以去抗議啊! 堅持要重打啊! 怎麼沒有人想到?
06/20 12:13, 179F
→
06/20 12:15, , 180F
贏球靠Ray也在哭，MJ靠Kerr Paxson、Shaq靠Fisher
06/20 12:15, 180F
→
06/20 12:15, , 181F
馬刺前幾場靠Green想必您也不齒吧LOL
06/20 12:15, 181F
推
06/20 12:18, , 182F
偷換人超委屈 都是紀錄組的錯 正義之師的刺刺不會錯
06/20 12:18, 182F
推
06/20 12:22, , 183F
迷迷酸酸呢??? 人呢??
06/20 12:22, 183F
推
06/20 12:23, , 184F
天啊，這真的讓人冒冷汗，這真的很可能變成一場災難
06/20 12:23, 184F
→
06/20 12:24, , 185F
不管是重打5秒鐘，或是鄧肯吃T熱火罰一球，這根本慘
06/20 12:24, 185F
→
06/20 12:25, , 186F
會把一場很精彩的比賽，變成一個眾人倒盡胃口的結果
06/20 12:25, 186F
推
06/20 12:30, , 187F
垃圾x刺
06/20 12:30, 187F
推
06/20 12:36, , 188F
樓上嘴巴好香 腦X
06/20 12:36, 188F
推
06/20 12:43, , 189F
那現在馬刺趕快抗議熱火罰一球重打阿
06/20 12:43, 189F
推
06/20 12:59, , 190F
說不定TD沒上馬刺就封王了勒 誰感謝誰還不知道
06/20 12:59, 190F
噓
06/20 13:09, , 191F
根本就沒延長賽 雷槍罰球會miss嗎 會
06/20 13:09, 191F
→
06/20 13:48, , 192F
馬刺就最會作弊啊 以前到現在都靠這種贏球
06/20 13:48, 192F
噓
06/20 13:53, , 193F
髒 垃圾馬刺
06/20 13:53, 193F
噓
06/20 14:00, , 194F
黑刺
06/20 14:00, 194F
推
06/20 14:03, , 195F
下場禁賽BJ4
06/20 14:03, 195F
噓
06/20 15:09, , 196F
這篇留言相較內文真的是超廢的,可以吵成這樣水準真高
06/20 15:09, 196F
推
06/20 15:49, , 197F
髒刺真的完全不意外啊
06/20 15:49, 197F
噓
06/20 15:54, , 198F
聯盟呷洨啦 實際上Pop對這暫停就超不爽的
06/20 15:54, 198F
噓
06/20 15:54, , 199F
明明就裁判要護航熱火可以完整回防才喊的
06/20 15:54, 199F
推
06/20 16:26, , 200F
熱火救了史騰
06/20 16:26, 200F
噓
06/20 17:04, , 201F
沒打過正式比賽的迷迷們在大聲什麼啦 換人經過裁判
06/20 17:04, 201F
噓
06/20 17:05, , 202F
就是裁判問題了 裁判沒準人走上去那才叫做弊好嗎 低
06/20 17:05, 202F
噓
06/20 17:23, , 203F
果然球員教練就跟球衣一樣黑 黑馬不意外
06/20 17:23, 203F
推
06/20 18:44, , 204F
TD若因為這樣又吃光頭一T...更添傳奇一筆XD
06/20 18:44, 204F
推
06/20 18:49, , 205F
那球是裁判暫停看回播，你重新上場偷換不用經過裁判.
06/20 18:49, 205F
→
06/20 18:49, , 206F
..你打比賽喊暫停換人上場要跟裁判講嗎？頗呵
06/20 18:49, 206F
噓
06/20 19:14, , 207F
實況 BOX一堆人噓黑火 結果....真諷刺
06/20 19:14, 207F
推
06/20 19:50, , 208F
爛重播規則,壞了比賽步調。換個人也沒發現，整個就
06/20 19:50, 208F
推
06/20 19:51, , 209F
火迷也只能不把這帳算在自己的場外隊友上了
06/20 19:51, 209F
噓
06/20 20:05, , 210F
拜託這哨還不是為了讓熱火回防 不然早就絕殺了
06/20 20:05, 210F
推
06/20 20:36, , 211F
gotohikaru沒看比賽喔 馬刺人都在三分線內是怎麼快攻
06/20 20:36, 211F
噓
06/20 22:03, , 212F
馬刺不意外
06/20 22:03, 212F
噓
06/20 23:37, , 213F
黑刺
06/20 23:37, 213F
噓
06/20 23:54, , 214F
哪不用經裁判跟紀錄臺？裁判發球前本就該確認上場球
06/20 23:54, 214F
→
06/20 23:55, , 215F
否上場，不然我犯滿一直暫停上去被抓在下來嗎？頗呵
06/20 23:55, 215F
推
06/24 09:01, , 216F
POPO也太老狐狸了XDDDD
06/24 09:01, 216F
噓
08/16 13:36, , 217F
刺迷頗ㄏ
08/16 13:36, 217F
‣ 更多 autumned 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HmcBh3_ (NBA)
NBA 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT體育區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 autumned 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HmcBh3_ (NBA)