[NFL!] NFL considers to abolish extra points

看板NFL (國家美式橄欖球聯盟)作者 (Socratic Machine Gun)時間12年前 (2014/01/21 15:44), 編輯推噓28(28019)
留言47則, 23人參與, 最新討論串1/1
簡單說 NFL 考慮全面廢除加踢 extra point, 以後只要 TD 就是七分. 你可以選擇用傳統進攻方式拿第八分, 不過如果失敗 TD 就變六分. 基本上沒有太大差異, 只是把加踢分該成自動算進而已.. 文中說支持這項改革的論點是 本季 1200 次加踢只有五球沒踢進, 在 pro-football level 加踢只是浪費時間而已 (有點好奇踢丟那五球的是那些人???) http://tinyurl.com/ln7bsqo NFL considering proposal to abolish extra points Speaking Monday, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said the league could eventually abolish the extra point. "The extra point is almost automatic," Goodell said. "I believe we had five missed extra points this year out of 1,200 some odd. So it's a very small fraction of the play, and you want to add excitement with every play." Goodell said the league is intrigued by a proposal that would automatically grant seven points for every touchdown, but still allow teams to try for an eighth point via a traditional offensive play. The catch is that if you fail to convert, the touchdown then becomes worth only six points. Perhaps the most perfunctory play in sports, extra points serve almost no purpose at the professional level. -- Sometimes I Go Commando -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 99.108.141.237

01/21 16:15, , 1F
禁止holder只許用drop kick不知道會不會有點看頭...
01/21 16:15, 1F

01/21 16:16, , 2F
可以換一個思考方式,如果領先6分被人達陣
01/21 16:16, 2F

01/21 16:17, , 3F
那有5/1200的機率可以BLOCK掉對方的後加踢分(?)
01/21 16:17, 3F

01/21 16:31, , 4F
我倒覺得這就跟棒球的IBB一樣,總還是有暴投的可能性
01/21 16:31, 4F

01/21 16:32, , 5F
那就不應該全面改掉,維持加踢分沒什麼壞處且還保有變數
01/21 16:32, 5F

01/21 16:37, , 6F
有一個是Vikings的Blair Walsh踢丟的XDD
01/21 16:37, 6F

01/21 16:38, , 7F
踢丟的瞬間,鏡頭還帶到AP一臉不敢相信的臉XDDDDDD
01/21 16:38, 7F

01/21 16:40, , 8F
或者改成從20yard的地方踢, 30yard FG就不算automatic吧?
01/21 16:40, 8F

01/21 16:40, , 9F
應該改成踢丟要倒扣六分.. 這樣比較緊張
01/21 16:40, 9F

01/21 16:48, , 10F
2011年海鷹的KICKER..看誰呢 就是說你Steven Hauschka
01/21 16:48, 10F

01/21 16:48, , 11F
全年4個踢丟的PAT就有2個是你..拜託你SB別放槍好嗎...
01/21 16:48, 11F

01/21 16:49, , 12F
沒有百分之百踢進這種事,就算沒踢偏也有可能Romo上身
01/21 16:49, 12F

01/21 17:24, , 13F
ROMO真是躺著也中槍
01/21 17:24, 13F

01/21 17:44, , 14F
我倒覺得extra point還具有讓 kicker 熱身的功能,熟悉
01/21 17:44, 14F

01/21 17:45, , 15F
賽場氣氛的功能。此制度宜修不宜廢,否則到時候我們就會
01/21 17:45, 15F

01/21 17:47, , 16F
看到kicker老是在旁納涼。
01/21 17:47, 16F

01/21 18:34, , 17F

01/21 18:35, , 18F
除了踢會沒踢進 發球也會失誤啊XD
01/21 18:35, 18F

01/21 18:38, , 19F
從20碼踢 那兩分轉換也要從20碼... 還不如自動算一分
01/21 18:38, 19F

01/21 20:10, , 20F
比賽就是有變數才好看 本來的extra point很好啊
01/21 20:10, 20F

01/21 21:01, , 21F
加踢時可以播重播TD的各角度 還有場邊表情特寫
01/21 21:01, 21F

01/21 21:32, , 22F
加踢時,就是轉台時間,或是廁所時間
01/21 21:32, 22F

01/21 22:33, , 23F
改成extra point block可以return好了~~~
01/21 22:33, 23F

01/21 23:59, , 24F
不是本來就可以return嗎..??還是只有大學可以return?
01/21 23:59, 24F

01/22 00:02, , 25F
不能 防守方拿到球就結束了
01/22 00:02, 25F

01/22 00:03, , 26F
其實可以加強extra point的難度,像rugby一樣
01/22 00:03, 26F

01/22 00:04, , 27F
在哪裡TD就在哪裡踢
01/22 00:04, 27F

01/22 00:05, , 28F
在線邊要怎麼列陣?
01/22 00:05, 28F

01/22 01:13, , 29F
football好看就是快節奏,我是覺得值得考慮。
01/22 01:13, 29F

01/22 01:58, , 30F
把球門改成會左右旋轉各三十度好了XD
01/22 01:58, 30F

01/22 03:43, , 31F
我喜歡看最後一秒 TD 變成 20:20
01/22 03:43, 31F

01/22 03:43, , 32F
然後靠著 extra point 贏球.
01/22 03:43, 32F

01/22 05:48, , 33F
01/22 05:48, 33F

01/22 06:58, , 34F
John Carney, classic.
01/22 06:58, 34F

01/22 10:49, , 35F
五個中應該有幾個是被block的
01/22 10:49, 35F

01/22 11:20, , 36F
在哪裡TD就在哪踢好刺激XDD 99 yards TD就有去了XDDDD
01/22 11:20, 36F

01/22 13:06, , 37F
像RUGBY那樣好像不錯..不過會不會太難...
01/22 13:06, 37F

01/22 18:01, , 38F
有人提議過誰TD就誰來踢,感覺很有趣
01/22 18:01, 38F

01/23 10:11, , 39F
這樣要加薪了...因為工作變多了...
01/23 10:11, 39F

01/23 13:55, , 40F
pick 6會變成pick 7嗎?
01/23 13:55, 40F

01/24 04:45, , 41F
誰 TD 誰來踢..那 punt return 太累了...跑得要死還要上來踢
01/24 04:45, 41F

01/24 04:45, , 42F
^ TD
01/24 04:45, 42F

01/24 12:07, , 43F
誰TD誰踢 那攻兩分就是誰傳球囉 XD
01/24 12:07, 43F

01/24 18:25, , 44F
所以結論是:天下本無事 庸人自擾之
01/24 18:25, 44F

01/26 21:53, , 45F
所以punt returner若是有機會TD或許會在goal line前自動
01/26 21:53, 45F

01/26 21:53, , 46F
減速或跪地
01/26 21:53, 46F

01/27 10:58, , 47F
如果廢了 假射門真搶兩分的戰術就看不到了
01/27 10:58, 47F
文章代碼(AID): #1ItYLcpv (NFL)
文章代碼(AID): #1ItYLcpv (NFL)