Re: Ellsbury wins Defensive Player of the Year

看板RedSox作者abc12812時間16年前 (2009/12/18 13:52)推噓2(2推 0噓 0→)

留言2則, 2人參與討論串5/7 (看更多)

※ 引述《abc12812 ()》之銘言： : ※ 引述《jayin07 ( ⊙o⊙)》之銘言： : : 看看現場看球的人怎麼講... : : http://www.myyesnetwork.com/12478/blog/2009/12/17/offense_vs._defense : : 節錄 : : Ellsbury was a fairly miserable center fielder last year—he’s fast, but his : : routes resemble a drunkard’s walk. In the smaller left field at Fenway, he : : might be forced to take better paths to the ball. Cabrera is a solid if : : unspectacular center fielder, and as with Damon, having to cover less ground : : should mean that his positives get accentuated and his limitations get : : minimized. Cabrera also has that terrific arm, which should mean a couple of : : runners who might have gone second-to-home on a single to Damon would get : : held up at third. : : 現在就是等field f/x正式上路... : 這作者很明顯是用數據看球賽，更糟的是他只看2009年的UZR : 實際上Ellsbury今年在ZR表現還不錯，排名算是前段班 : TotalZone從小聯盟一路上來都高於平均甚多 (唯一的例外是今年，不過也只有-5) : PMR今年還沒出來，不過看去年的表現也和爛這個字扯不上關係 : 頂多就是中線防守略差，但兩側防守很好 : 看+/-也沒多大問題 : 要我說的話，Ellsbury防守再差也很難輸給Melky Mantle : 至少Ellsbury在轉播時沒有判斷問題，但Melky Mantle我們都知道他接平飛球的鳥樣然後防守數據不同年變動大我想也不是新鮮事了 Coco Crisp 2007年UZR是24，隔年變-8 (然後就被ㄏㄇㄉㄉ說他防守不好) Curtis Granderson 2007年是14，隔年變-9 Mike Cameron 2007年是-10，隔年變11 Adam Jones去年有10，今年變-4 所以我認為要用數據評斷Ellsbury的防守，還要再多個幾年觀察期吧 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.112.5.3