Re: [新聞] 影／鐵頭功無效！少林第一武僧被美國警 …
看板MartialArts (武術 - 格鬥)作者jkwusun (嘴砲妖僧)時間15年前 (2010/12/17 19:33)推噓10(11推 1噓 36→)留言48則, 9人參與討論串11/28 (看更多)
推
12/17 19:27,
12/17 19:27
→
12/17 19:27,
12/17 19:27
→
12/17 19:28,
12/17 19:28
Schwartz et al found that similar gloves used to
punch a viscoelastic dummy head did not mitigate the
accelerations that may produce brain injury.
The utility of MMA gloves is therefore probably negligible and may protect
the attacker’s hands more than the defender’s head.
出自
G J Buse
No holds barred sport fighting: a 10 year review of mixed
martial arts competition
Br. J. Sports Med. 2006;40:169–172.
不需要我幫你英翻中吧?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.96.198.14
→
12/17 19:34, , 1F
12/17 19:34, 1F
→
12/17 19:35, , 2F
12/17 19:35, 2F
→
12/17 19:36, , 3F
12/17 19:36, 3F
Buse 引述的 Schwartz那篇論文沒有電子期刊
不過有些圖書館會有微縮或紙本 我還是希望你能自己去看
該文提到 以DUMMY頭部最大加速度來說薄拳套與裸拳並無顯著差異
當年估算腦部損傷的模型HIC(Head injury criterion)尚未被導出
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head_injury_criterion
不過我們由hic公式可以看出腦傷與腦部所受加速度變化量有關
所以若手套接觸時間與裸拳也無顯著差異 那腦部所受的損傷可能也差不多
並無顯著差異就是說
兩者的差別大概是刀子跟扁鑽的差別 不是刀子跟棉花的差別
當然 這是老研究了 也許材料技術進步了 新的全套比較能減震
※ 編輯: jkwusun 來自: 140.96.198.14 (12/17 19:51)
噓
12/17 19:53, , 4F
12/17 19:53, 4F
→
12/17 19:54, , 5F
12/17 19:54, 5F
推
12/17 19:56, , 6F
12/17 19:56, 6F
推
12/17 20:05, , 7F
12/17 20:05, 7F
→
12/17 20:06, , 8F
12/17 20:06, 8F
→
12/17 20:07, , 9F
12/17 20:07, 9F
→
12/17 22:29, , 10F
12/17 22:29, 10F
→
12/17 22:30, , 11F
12/17 22:30, 11F
→
12/17 22:31, , 12F
12/17 22:31, 12F
→
12/17 22:33, , 13F
12/17 22:33, 13F
→
12/17 22:33, , 14F
12/17 22:33, 14F
我沒有讀過類似的研究
不過上面的wiki裡指出
"Gloves may reduce the amount of eye injuries,
especially if they are thumbless"
所以似乎這樣講是可以的
※ 編輯: jkwusun 來自: 140.96.198.14 (12/17 22:37)
推
12/17 23:33, , 15F
12/17 23:33, 15F
→
12/17 23:33, , 16F
12/17 23:33, 16F
→
12/17 23:34, , 17F
12/17 23:34, 17F
Schwartz ML, Hudson AR, Fernie GR, et al. Biomechanical study of full-contact
karate contrasted with boxing. J Neurosurg 1986;64:248–52.
我還在學校的時候這種老研究沒有電子期刊 官僚大學附設醫院只有微縮
剛剛去看有全文pdf了
公園沒有買JNS 但是醫大應該會有 N君可以去找來看看
14個空手道黑帶subject
統計方法我倒沒有看到 只說他用的軟體是GLIM 我猜是pair-t
※ 編輯: jkwusun 來自: 140.96.198.14 (12/18 00:13)
推
12/18 00:30, , 18F
12/18 00:30, 18F
→
12/18 00:30, , 19F
12/18 00:30, 19F
→
12/18 00:31, , 20F
12/18 00:31, 20F
→
12/18 00:31, , 21F
12/18 00:31, 21F
→
12/18 00:31, , 22F
12/18 00:31, 22F
→
12/18 00:32, , 23F
12/18 00:32, 23F
→
12/18 00:32, , 24F
12/18 00:32, 24F
→
12/18 00:32, , 25F
12/18 00:32, 25F
→
12/18 00:32, , 26F
12/18 00:32, 26F
→
12/18 00:34, , 27F
12/18 00:34, 27F
→
12/18 00:35, , 28F
12/18 00:35, 28F
推
12/18 00:36, , 29F
12/18 00:36, 29F
→
12/18 00:36, , 30F
12/18 00:36, 30F
→
12/18 00:37, , 31F
12/18 00:37, 31F
→
12/18 00:38, , 32F
12/18 00:38, 32F
推
12/18 02:41, , 33F
12/18 02:41, 33F
→
12/18 02:42, , 34F
12/18 02:42, 34F
→
12/18 02:42, , 35F
12/18 02:42, 35F
→
12/18 02:42, , 36F
12/18 02:42, 36F
→
12/18 02:43, , 37F
12/18 02:43, 37F
→
12/18 02:43, , 38F
12/18 02:43, 38F
推
12/18 06:20, , 39F
12/18 06:20, 39F
→
12/18 08:29, , 40F
12/18 08:29, 40F
→
12/18 12:43, , 41F
12/18 12:43, 41F
推
12/18 13:54, , 42F
12/18 13:54, 42F
→
12/18 13:54, , 43F
12/18 13:54, 43F
推
12/19 17:24, , 44F
12/19 17:24, 44F
→
12/21 01:35, , 45F
12/21 01:35, 45F
→
12/21 01:37, , 46F
12/21 01:37, 46F
推
12/21 02:01, , 47F
12/21 02:01, 47F
推
12/21 02:06, , 48F
12/21 02:06, 48F
討論串 (同標題文章)
MartialArts 近期熱門文章
PTT體育區 即時熱門文章
